Schedule
a free roofing
estimate today!

Inner Coupons
Gray standing seam metal roof with skylights, chimneys, and snow guards on a house under construction.

Asphalt vs. Cedar Shake Roofing in New England: Pros and Cons

Put a roof on your New England home and you have to make some decisions. Is the classic cedar shake worth the premium over asphalt shingles? Which is going to hold up to our long winters and humid summers?

Homeowners put that question to us all the time, so you are not alone in asking it. It is one of the most frequent inquiries we get and one we like to give a straight answer to. JP Carroll Roofing, LLC has been at it since 1987, putting more than 30,000 roofs in place across New England. Should you want to run your options by someone in person, give us a ring at (860) 775-7511.

There is no denying both asphalt and cedar shake have their place on a New England house. They are two very different materials with their own particular strengths. We will go over them here to help you come to the right conclusion for your budget and your home.

What is behind the popularity of asphalt shingles

For good reason, asphalt is America’s roofing material of choice. Few things can match the way it combines style, durability and cost.

Some of what draws homeowners to asphalt:

  • It is friendlier to the budget than cedar as an initial outlay
  • You have plenty of colors and styles to pick from, even architectural shingles that pass for wood or slate
  • The job gets done in less time
  • It puts up a good fight against the wind, rain and freeze-thaw we see in this part of the country
  • Warranties can be extensive; a certified contractor can put down GAF Golden Pledge coverage for as much as 50 years

We are members of the GAF President’s Club, an honor held by under 1% of contractors in the nation, and the premium asphalt systems we put in are made to weather New England.

Then again, it is not without fault. A standard three-tab shingle has a shorter life than the top tier products. And asphalt will never have the rustic appeal of cedar. For some, the look is as important as how it works.

Why go with cedar shake

Cedar has a natural beauty of its own that asphalt falls short of. On a Colonial or an old Cape or any New England farmhouse it is quite a sight.

Here is what you get with cedar:

  • The warm wood tones that will turn a fine silver-gray with age
  • Some insulating value for better energy efficiency
  • A high-end finish that adds to the curb appeal and resale price
  • Decades of service if you put in the maintenance
  • An old-fashioned feel in keeping with many of our neighborhoods

It is a statement piece, in a way, and conveys quality.

You do have to make some allowances though. Cedar is more expensive to buy and put on. It needs more tending to as well. In the humidity of New England it is susceptible to moss, mold and rot unless it is seen to regularly. Fire is a factor too, although treated cedar can be had.

The climate factor

Our weather is hard on a roof. Between the ice dams, heavy snow, the occasional coastal squall and the summer dampness, a roof has to be up to it.

Asphalt is the more accommodating option for our climate. With the right underlayment it is resistant to ice damage and sheds water without much fuss. Cedar will do fine but only if you are on top of the maintenance. Those not prepared for the upkeep may find it a chore.

In the end, how well the job is done trumps the material. A substandard installation on a top of the line roof will not last as long as a proper one on a regular roof. That is the case for using a licensed and insured contractor.

Making your call

There is not one correct choice. For a long warranty and less hassle, you are better off with asphalt. If you have the desire to maintain it for the sake of the looks, cedar is a fine option.

We would be happy to talk it over with you. Our second-generation family leadership has been serving Massachusetts, Connecticut, New Hampshire, Vermont and Rhode Island and we put the same care into every roof as we would our own. Whatever you choose, our roofing services cover the full installation from start to finish.

We are here seven days a week from 7:30am until 9:00pm and offer free estimates as well as 0% financing via GreenSky. Call JP Carroll Roofing, LLC at (860) 775-7511 and we will put you on the right roof.

Pristine craftsmanship
since 1987

see what customers
are saying

Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)

 

At JP Carroll Roofing, we are committed to ensuring that individuals with disabilities enjoy full access to our websites. In recognition of this commitment, we are in the process of making modifications to increase the accessibility and usability of this website, using the relevant portions of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.0 (WCAG 2.0) as our standard. Please be aware that our efforts are ongoing. If at any time you have difficulty using this website or with a particular web page or function on this site, please contact us by phone at (866) 284-5088 or email us at admin@jpcarrollroofing.com and place “Web Content Accessibility (ADA)” in the subject heading and we will make all reasonable efforts to assist you.

Thank You

Thanks for requesting a free estimate. We’ll be in touch shortly to discuss pricing and availability.